Prom Night Gone Bad: An '80s Murder Mystery Dinner at New Leaf Cafe

Break out the hairspray and leg warmers. New Leaf Cafe is turning back the clock for “Totally Rad ’80s Prom Gone Bad,” a murder mystery dinner on Saturday, Nov. 14, beginning at 6 p.m.

The event is a fundraiser for Orcas Center. Tickets are $195 per person and include dinner prepared by New Leaf and drinks like Bloody Carrie and Pretty in Pink. Seating is limited; you can purchase tickets at www.orcascenter.org. Please note your menu preference (vegan or non-vegan) when booking. During the ticket buying process, you will have an option to select your level of involvement, from main characters, secondary characters, or ensemble observers.

Guests will arrive at the Mayhem High Senior Prom, where the crowning of prom king and queen is the biggest event of the year, until someone ends up dead. Over a multi-course dinner, diners will mingle with the suspects, gather clues and try to name the killer before the final reveal. The winner will receive four tickets to a show of their choice in the 2026-27 season. Guests are encouraged to dress up in audacious 1980s attire. Think glamour, big bangs, color and taffeta.

Starts: November 14, 2026

Time: 6:00 pm

Admission: $195

Location: New Leaf Cafe
171 Main St, Eastsound, WA 98245

View Website

Contact Us:
San Juan Islands Visitors Bureau
info@visitsanjuans.com
1-888-468-3701 x1 | (360) 378-9551 x1
P.O. Box 1330, Friday Harbor, Washington 98250
Subscribe to E-newsletter:
We are a membership organization. More tourism-oriented businesses and non-profits can be found on the three Chamber of Commerce's websites.
Additional Resources/Visitor Info Centers

Site by Drozian Webworks
©2026 San Juan Islands Visitors Bureau
Privacy Policy